8 Marketing recruitment challenges and how to overcome them

Recruiting top talent for marketing roles is an intricate process that presents numerous challenges. From finding candidates with the right skill sets to balancing immediate needs with long-term goals, the task requires a strategic approach tailored specifically to the marketing landscape.

View our marketing recruitment services.

Marketing recruitment challenges

1. Attracting the best talent in a competitive market

Challenge:

The demand for skilled marketing professionals is high, making it difficult to attract top talent. The Bureau of Labour Statistics projects a 10% growth in marketing jobs from 2022 to 2032, faster than the average for all occupations. This competitive landscape means that the best candidates are often fielding multiple offers.

Solution:

To attract top talent, companies should:

• Build a strong employer brand: Promote your company culture, values, and benefits through various channels, including social media, company websites, and employee testimonials. A positive employer brand can significantly enhance your appeal to potential candidates.
• Offer competitive salaries: Ensure that your salary and benefits packages are competitive. Use industry benchmarks to set attractive offers and consider flexible work arrangements, which have become increasingly important post-pandemic.
• Engage in Active Recruitment: Don’t rely solely on job postings. Proactively reach out to potential candidates through LinkedIn and professional networks. Attend industry events and conferences to meet prospective employees in person.

View our latest marketing salary guide

2. Assessing qualifications on CV’s

Challenge:

A common issue in marketing recruitment is candidates exaggerating their qualifications and soft skills. According to a 2023 LinkedIn survey, 30% of marketing professionals admitted to embellishing their CV’s to secure interviews. This makes it difficult to discern genuine expertise from overstatements.

Solution:

To cut through exaggerated qualifications, companies should:

• Conduct in-depth interviews: Use behavioural and situational questions to evaluate a candidate’s real-world experience. For example, ask candidates to describe a challenging marketing campaign they managed and the results they achieved.
• Check references thoroughly: Verify the candidate’s past performance by speaking with previous employers and colleagues. Cross-check details provided in the resume with those given by references.
• Use real-world scenarios: Present candidates with scenarios relevant to your business and ask them to outline their approach. This helps in assessing their problem-solving abilities and practical knowledge.

3. Identifying the right skill set

Challenge:

Marketing has evolved rapidly with digital transformation, creating a demand for professionals who are not only creative but also proficient in data analytics, SEO, content marketing, and social media management. According to a 2023 survey by LinkedIn, 87% of marketing executives believe the skills required for their jobs have changed significantly over the past five years. This shift has made it challenging to find candidates who possess the right combination of skills.

Solution:

To identify the right skill set, companies should:

• Clearly define job roles: Develop detailed job descriptions that specify the required skills and experiences. This helps to attract candidates whose profiles match your needs.
• Utilise skills assessments: Implement practical tests during the recruitment process to evaluate candidates’ abilities in key areas such as SEO, content creation, and data analysis.
• Leverage data analytics: Use data-driven tools to analyse past successful hires and determine which skills and experiences are most predictive of success in your organization.

4. Finding generalist candidates

Challenge:

The trend toward specialization in marketing has made it difficult to find generalists who can handle a broad range of responsibilities. The American Marketing Association reported in 2023 that 65% of marketing roles are now specialized, focusing on areas like SEO, content marketing, or social media.

Solution:

To find marketing generalists, companies should:

• Look for versatile backgrounds: Seek candidates with diverse experience across various marketing functions. Smaller companies often provide broader exposure, making such candidates valuable.
• Assess adaptability: Evaluate a candidate’s ability to learn new skills and adapt to different tasks. This can be gauged through past experiences and their willingness to take on diverse projects.
• Prioritize cross-functional skills: Identify candidates with skills that span multiple areas of marketing, such as project management, strategic thinking, and communication. These skills are crucial for generalist roles.

5. Balancing needs

Challenge:

Balancing short-term needs with long-term goals is a significant challenge in marketing recruitment. Companies often need quick results to meet immediate demands while planning for future growth. According to Gartner’s 2024 report, 70% of marketing leaders are prioritizing short-term performance over long-term strategy.

Solution:

To balance these needs, companies should:

• Develop a workforce plan: Create a strategic workforce plan that aligns with business objectives. This plan should outline immediate staffing needs as well as long-term goals for growth and development.
• Prioritize flexibility: Hire a mix of full-time employees and freelancers to meet immediate needs while maintaining flexibility for future changes.
• Focus on potential: Look for candidates who not only meet current requirements but also show potential for future growth and development within the company.

6. Evaluating copywriting talent

Challenge:

Determining whether a candidate has natural copywriting abilities can be challenging, as it’s a skill that often goes beyond what’s listed on a resume or showcased in a portfolio. Combining this, the rise of AI content tools has made assessing copywriting skills even more difficult. Copywriting is critical for creating compelling marketing content that drives engagement and conversions.

Solution:

To identify natural copywriting talent, companies should:

• Use practical writing tests: Incorporate practical writing tests into the interview process to evaluate a candidate’s ability to produce engaging and effective copy. For instance, ask candidates to create a campaign slogan or a product description during the interview.
• Assess creativity and style: Look for candidates who demonstrate creativity and a unique writing style. Review their writing samples to see if they can capture different brand voices effectively.
• Evaluate consistency: Ensure that the candidate can maintain a consistent voice and tone across different types of content and platforms. Consistency is key to building a strong brand identity.

7. Ensuring diversity and inclusion

Challenge:

Achieving diversity and inclusion in marketing teams is essential for creativity and innovation. However, many companies struggle to build diverse teams. A 2023 McKinsey report found that diverse teams are 35% more likely to outperform their non-diverse counterparts, yet many organizations still lack adequate representation.

Solution:

To ensure diversity and inclusion, companies should:

• Implement inclusive hiring practices: Use blind recruitment techniques to reduce bias in the hiring process. Ensure job postings are inclusive and appeal to a diverse range of candidates.
• Promote an inclusive culture: Foster a workplace environment where all employees feel respected and valued. This includes offering diversity training and establishing employee resource groups.
• Monitor and measure progress: Regularly assess your diversity metrics and set clear goals for improvement. Use employee surveys and feedback to gauge the effectiveness of your diversity initiatives.

8. Retaining marketing talent

Challenge:

High turnover rates in the marketing industry can disrupt team dynamics and hinder long-term projects. A 2023 report by the American Marketing Association found that the average tenure of a marketing professional is just 2.6 years. Frequent turnover can lead to lost knowledge and continuity issues.

Solution:

To retain marketing talent, companies should:

• Prioritise professional development: Provide opportunities for continuous learning and career advancement. Offer training programs, mentorship, and clear career progression paths.
• Promote a positive work environment: Create a supportive and inclusive workplace culture where employees feel valued and engaged. Regularly seek feedback and address any issues that arise promptly.
• Reward performance: Implement recognition programs that celebrate employee achievements. This can include formal awards, bonuses, and public acknowledgment of individual and team successes.

Conclusion

Marketing recruitment poses unique challenges that require tailored strategies to overcome. Addressing these challenges head-on will not only improve your recruitment process but also drive your marketing team’s success in an increasingly competitive landscape.

Are you looking to hire for your marketing team? We are a specialist marketing recruitment agency, ready to help you find candidates ahead of your competition. Contact us today.